Monday, October 28, 2013

A Cross in Fillmore Chapel? Inquiry by Judi Marshall



A Cross in Fillmore Chapel? Inquiry by Judi Marshall

When we look at the history of the cross we find it is a symbol of pain suffering and death on a cross. 
The history of crucifixion extends as far back as the Assyrians, Phoenicians and Persians of the first millennium B.C., as well as some Greeks throughout the Hellenized world.
Because the main purpose of this practice was to punish, humiliate and frighten disobedient slaves, the practice did not necessarily result in death. Only in later times, probably in the first century B.C., did crucifixion evolve into a method of execution for conviction of certain crimes.1
1Bible History Daily Biblical Archaeology society www.biblicalarchaeology.org/.../crucifixion/a-tomb-in-jerusalem-reveals
  
      “The Romans did not invent crucifixion as a method of execution, though it seems that they perfected it.”2  2http://www.orlutheran.com/html/crucify.html It was chosen to represent [and] considered to be the most humiliating painful excruciating form of death done by the Romans.

On what grounds then, would followers of the Unity Movement reinterpret an instrument of torture and put it in our sanctuaries.  On what grounds would followers of the Unity Movement take what became a symbol of atonement for the sins of humanity in traditional Christianity and place it in our sanctuaries.  As one Unity minister shared with me, as we discussed the common practice of taking of other’s rituals and practices incorporating them into our Unity spiritual services, “just because we can doesn’t mean we should.”

Would we put a cross up in the chapel because it is holy or would it be holy because we put it up? In doing so we would have to reclaim the cross and cleanse it of the blood of sacrifice. We would have to reinterpret it and put our very own Unity definition on it.   And for what purpose?

In this light why would a cross be fitting for Unity?  Other methods of execution were done in the Ancient Near East: Stoning, beheadings, burnings, sewing a person in a bag with a snake, dog, chicken and rooster and thrown in water, torn apart by lions, scourging.  If Jesus had been executed by one of these methods would we be wearing necklaces of large stones, swords, fire, a bag with little miniatures inside?  A lion perhaps? Or a whip? Why then the cross?  If Jesus showed up today and was once again found guilty of treason because he accused the powers that be of gross social injustice and moral decay and he was then executed by electric chair would we all be wearing little electric chairs and put one in our sanctuary?  

Why not use the symbols we have or create a new one just as other practices have done for centuries.


2 comments:

  1. Very thought provoking! It really is a perversion of the tool of death to be venerated as a sacred icon. As a child going to Catholic School, I was always scared and grossed out by the humongous crucifix behind the alter. A replica of Jesus was hanging there suffering. It just seemed macabre.

    I'm certain as Unity is an enlightened movement; the cross/crucifix would be contrary to what we stand for. As Dr. Tom mentions, in Glimpses on page 13, "We are a Christmas Faith in an Easter World." We celebrate the birth of our way shower, the recognition that we too can become the Christ. If crosses become our symbol of faith wouldn't we be saying Jesus is John's Jesus, a divine being-God and separate from the likes of us mere mortals? To me that turns most of our beliefs upside down.

    Thank for the dialogue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the best question you asked is, "Would we put a cross up in the chapel because it is holy or would it be holy because we put it up?" I seems that if we used the "symbols we have" we would be using them because they were holy, whereas if we "created new symbols" then the symbols would be holy because we used them.

    ReplyDelete