Ethnocentrism in the Unity Movement?
When one reviews the Biblical history of Jewish people, one begins to notice a written history of conquest, defeat and exile; conquest, defeat and exile by the Assyrians, the Babylonians, the Greeks, and Romans. There were the Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, Pogroms in Eastern Europe culminating with the Holocaust 1939 – 1944. It is said “the phoenix rising from the ashes of the Holocaust went on to create the state of Israel. And thus began the Arab Israeli Wars in 1948, 1967, 1973, 1982, and Palestinian uprisings and battles up to the present time.
“Every group assumes their way [to be] the proper, correct, natural way for humans to live. This is called ethnocentrism, i.e., the tendency for each group to assume the superiority of its beliefs and practices” (P. 78 Shepherd, Glimpses of Truth). And it appears that over the history of the Jewish people one ethnocentric group after another asserted their superiority.
I have always wondered how a group of people can remain in a state of constant warfare protecting their survival. What does it do to their view of the world and when does the oppressed become the oppressor?
A sense of ethnocentrism, a sense of “our way” is best and it is the only way, evolves to protect a group. It provides a sense of belonging identity as well as protection. It also ensures the group staying intact with their own identity by not allowing questioning of the beliefs or the incorporation of any new ideas perhaps relevant to the time and culture in which they live. To question is to be disrespectful and bring dishonor to the community. Any alternatives or new ways of looking at the world are considered dangerous to the group or community.
I perceive ethnocentrism rising in the Unity community. Yes, I hear “my way is good and yours is bad.” “You are not teaching Unity.” “You are allowing our doors to be open to other influences that are “infiltrating” Unity Churches and Centers.” “Jesus is no longer the head of the Institute.” “They have thrown out my Jesus.” “My God no longer exists in Unity.” “The Institute no longer teaches Fillmore.” What began as a conversation questioning curriculum, in Unity turned into a discussion of what Unity Churches, now called “Centers,” are offering, and has now become a full blown division between what was and what is.
I think the questioning within the movement is good. It causes us to look at and examine our beliefs. As Stone and Duke write “Nearly all Christian doctrines or teachings …set forth in the historic creeds were composed in response to controversies over conflicting embedded theologies…To grow in faith is to deepen, extend, and perhaps revise our understanding of its meaning and to arrive at clearer mean by which to state an act on our convictions” ((pp. 20-21). How To Think Theologically).
“Ethnocentrism only becomes a problem for a group when it draws the negative conclusion: If our way is good, your way is un-good” (p. 79 Shepherd, Glimpses of Truth). Yes, by allowing questioning of the old and even the new, we make our selves vulnerable. “It means finding our own peculiar brand of nonsense and allowing our neighbor to go and do likewise” (p. 86 Glimpses of Truth). Here’s to the dialogue!
Poignant and timely. Unity is going through immense shifts. I agree with you to keep the dialogue going and allow each person to find their own truth.
ReplyDeleteIt had not occurred to me to extend this discussion to what is happening within the Unity movement, but I am glad that you did. There are important questions and discussions that are ongoing, and I have been guilty of dismissing some of them. Your post has helped me to realize that I have been "off my card" as Gary Simmons would say, and have been showing up in some circles in a way that is less than loving and accepting. Thank you, thank you, for giving me pause.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very important dialogue that we need to be aware of and informed about. My home church was literally torn apart by it a little over five years ago while I was attending Unity Institute in 2008 and 2009. When I returned home my church had split in two. It was a painful and disheartening experience. I went with the more liberal spin off group and became one of the founding members of Austin's newest Unity Church, known as the Downtown Unity Circle, which I am pleased to say is healthy and growing.
ReplyDeleteJudy, I applaud you for speaking the truth and for bringing to light that which has seemingly been swept under the rug. Some may be unaware of the discord within the Unity movement and I think you are bring up excellent points and I agree with you, these kinds of discussions can deepen our faith.
ReplyDelete